dollar, magician hat, sleepy face, no division by zero, plus sign, ugly face, uhhh no idea what is this one, wizard, bug under looking glass, check your thoughts, cocaine, broken chain, unbroken chain, delta (I thought we already had this one)
best guesses: valuable, hat tip, disappointed, right assumption wrong conclusion, +1, disgusted, gut feeling, moloch, subtle detail, agreed, magic smell, broken link, link redirect, this is the diff
I wonder if it would be cheap/worthwhile to just get a bunch of people to guess for a variety of symbols to see what’s actually intuitive?
Economics, magician, sigh, ???, ditto, disgusting, easy to digest, moloch, found a bug, yup that’s what I said, passes the sniff test, missing link, not missing link in argument chain, and marginally changed my mind.
Guesses: Bounty, magical thinking, bummer, clear division/separation, +1, made me angry, long thoughts/time spent thinking, sage, exposed an error, good communication, good post smell?/vibes, broken argument, strong argument, moved my position on the topic
Experimental new reacts coming soon… (image visible on click)
Answers! Of interest to: @Viliam @Raymond Douglas @Garrett Baker @Nina Panickssery @Perhaps @Mateusz Bagiński
Let’s make a bet!
Bowing Out
Sad
Agree Denotationally, Disagree Connotationally
(H/T badger)
Plus One
Too Sneering
“I beseech you!”
(H/T Cromwell’s Rule)
Moloch
Nitpick
Question Answered
Smells like LLM
Strong Argument
Weak Argument
Changed My Mind (on this point)
@dirk What do you think is the typo? I asked ChatGPT if my spelling was non-standard and it said ‘nitpicking’ is standard.
Oh, maybe are point out that there’s no apostrophe in my use of the word “its” in the description.
surprised we needed a cocaine emoji
dollar, magician hat, sleepy face, no division by zero, plus sign, ugly face, uhhh no idea what is this one, wizard, bug under looking glass, check your thoughts, cocaine, broken chain, unbroken chain, delta (I thought we already had this one)
You are right!
About one of them.
Better luck next time on the other 13.
I’m actually surprised the wizard one wasn’t obvious (on reflection I am typical minding way too hard here).
best guesses: valuable, hat tip, disappointed, right assumption wrong conclusion, +1, disgusted, gut feeling, moloch, subtle detail, agreed, magic smell, broken link, link redirect, this is the diff
I wonder if it would be cheap/worthwhile to just get a bunch of people to guess for a variety of symbols to see what’s actually intuitive?
This is fun! I’ll post answers tomorrow. Lots of close guesses, but this overall scores 2⁄14. (Note that we already have disappointed and agreed.)
I’d bet (at like 5:1) that nobody can guess 4 or 7. (7 is kind of a silly/novelty one.)
I’m surprised 9 and 11 aren’t obvious.
Economics, magician, sigh, ???, ditto, disgusting, easy to digest, moloch, found a bug, yup that’s what I said, passes the sniff test, missing link, not missing link in argument chain, and marginally changed my mind.
Oh, moloch, of course!
2⁄14 (I’m being generous with ‘ditto’). The last two are v close guesses.
Guesses:
Bounty, magical thinking, bummer, clear division/separation, +1, made me angry, long thoughts/time spent thinking, sage, exposed an error, good communication, good post smell?/vibes, broken argument, strong argument, moved my position on the topic
I’m seeing:
coin: “I would bet on this”
top hat: maybe “this is high status” or “I tip my hat to you”?
downcast face: “this makes me sad” / “disappointing truth” / “alas!”
check/X: “don’t know if I agree” or “agree in part, not in whole”
plus sign: “sign me up!” / “I am on board with this” / “I have this pattern”
wincing face: “this makes me disgusted”
intestines: “this matches my gut feeling”
Baphomet: either “this spends weirdness points” or “this is excessively occult/mystical/conspiratorial”
insect under glass:
“this correctly identifies a bug”“this is nitpicking”check in speech balloon: “you seem to be agreeing loudly”
nose: “this smells” / “something is wrong here but I don’t know what”
unlinked links: “there is a missing inferential step here”
linked links: “this supplies a missing inferential step”
delta w/dot: “this changed my mind away from its expressed position”
4: good reasoning/argument, wrong conclusion
Very nice! I’m especially loving the nose (and the intestine)! Looking forward to finding out exactly what these are supposed to mean.
Guesses:
“I’d bet on this”
Hat tip == “Respect”
“This makes me sad”
“Balanced”
“+1”
“This makes me disgusted”
(Joking) “You are full of shit”
(or maybe “My gut agrees”)
“This is evil”
“Nitpicking”
“Correctly understood what I said”
“Passes the sniff test”
“Argument missing a step”
“Argument not missing a step”
Divergence operator == “Off topic”?
Divergence uses a nabla not a delta
Ugh yes, oops