Huh, I feel like it’s pretty good for that purpose? If you want a list of posts that were popular but not endorsed, just take the difference between the highly upvoted posts and the review results.
The only requirement for a posts to enter the review phase is that anyone thinks it still has anything going for it. As such, if a post is obviously a fad, it won’t end up thoroughly reviewed, but if it’s really that common-knowledge that it was a fad, that seems fine. And even then, we still occasionally have people nominate posts for review just because they think they are bad and want people to do a retrospective on them.
One thing I want to remind people: if something looks like it’s going to end up winning the review, and you disagree with it, if you write up a critical review that gets upvoted (10+ karma), it’ll show up whenever we spotlight the review. This may not be fully satisfying if you were really hoping to change everyone’s mind, but it does mean you
For example, AI Control was one of the leading candidates from the last review, but, John’s countertake is highlighted for people who are skimming through the /bestoflesswrong page.
Huh, I feel like it’s pretty good for that purpose? If you want a list of posts that were popular but not endorsed, just take the difference between the highly upvoted posts and the review results.
The only requirement for a posts to enter the review phase is that anyone thinks it still has anything going for it. As such, if a post is obviously a fad, it won’t end up thoroughly reviewed, but if it’s really that common-knowledge that it was a fad, that seems fine. And even then, we still occasionally have people nominate posts for review just because they think they are bad and want people to do a retrospective on them.
One thing I want to remind people: if something looks like it’s going to end up winning the review, and you disagree with it, if you write up a critical review that gets upvoted (10+ karma), it’ll show up whenever we spotlight the review. This may not be fully satisfying if you were really hoping to change everyone’s mind, but it does mean you
For example, AI Control was one of the leading candidates from the last review, but, John’s countertake is highlighted for people who are skimming through the /bestoflesswrong page.