My model of “What LW as a community considers a good post” is not accurate enough for my taste. Sometimes I don’t understand the karma/number of comments (or lack thereof) of some posts, and it seems rude or arrogant to ask (whether it’s someone else’s post or one of mine). Among other things, this might help me decide whether to spend the hours necessary to write a post, or if it’s not the kind of ideas people are interested in here.
So I’m asking you, yes you, what makes a LW post that you want to read. That you want to upvote or strong upvote. That you might comment. A good post, basically.