I was coming on here to say that this doesn’t take into account all of the kids that aren’t very motivated by money. I‘ve tried paying my son for things like this, but he’s not interested. he does way better with intrinsic motivation.
Then I realized that the intrinsic motivation would still exist, and therefore this would be for students who are easily extrinsically motivated. My nephew is. He’s not even a teenager, and bought a portable pressure washer to make money in the neighborhood. I think he’d be motivated to go to school and participate.
The biggest issue I see is cost. Education has been severely underfunded, and this would increase the cost. According to Google, there were about 49.6 million gradeschool students in the US in 2022. Assuming that the grades are distributed evenly, on average we’re talking around 150 million per day, nation-wide. With about 180 school days in a year, we’re looking at 27 billion dollars.
That’s well within the range of federal government budgeting, but given the track record, that seems very unlikely.
I think it would be worth studying. I’d want to know how much that money affects outcomes, and what payment thresholds produce what kind of results. I’m skeptical that it would be a better than the money going to teacher pay, but it’s worth finding out.
This is one advantage of polyamory. It’s not discussed much, but it’s the kind of thing you see when someone gets hurt. When my girlfriend broke her leg, me and her other partner were able to coordinate and help her more than either of us could alone.