“A rationalist community better at following its ideals would be explicitly antifascist/antiracist/antisexist/etc, and explicitly exclusionary of many fascists/racists/reactionaries/etc it currently tolerates. The community’s current norms around political tolerance and neutrality are more rooted in exclusion trauma, upper-middle-class conflict avoidance norms, and a desire to protect politically valent false beliefs from scrutiny, rather than any aid those norms bring to the community’s rationality.”
I’ve been intending to write a more careful and less provocative version of this into a post or sequence of posts for a while, so I figured I would post the basic thesis in this somewhat safer thread to get the ball rolling. Apologies for doing the more inflammatory version first; hopefully I’ll find time to write the more careful version sometime in the next few months or so.
I haven’t gotten very far into it yet, but Kevin Carson’s The Homebrew Industrial Revolution explores this question in some detail (though in a fairly opinionated way).