But—surely—China has a functioning market economy, where you can incentivize things by paying for them? Sure it’s “Communist” but it’s not communist like that.
I have lots of uncertainty about this! For example, it does appear that China basically gutted its software startup industry a few months ago, and this is really costly, and it wouldn’t surprise me if this will have large negative effects on Chinese drone effectiveness, since software seems like a non-trivial fraction of the difficulty, especially for coordinating drone swarms.
My current model is that overall, all things considered, the Chinese market economy is a lot weaker. This doesn’t mean there are no domains where China excells at building great products in their market economy, but I have a much higher likelihood that something will mess up their efforts to do something in the market than I have for the U.S.. IDK, I am at like 65% that the US market economy is sufficiently stronger here to produce a long-run advantage in drone manufacturing if the US government decides to spend heavily on it, which really isn’t that confident.
Since I feel like these kinds of discussions can often feel thankless, I felt like I wanted to write an explicit comment saying I am grateful for @1a3orn’s, @JohnofCharleston’s, @Thomas Kwa’s and @Alexander Gietelink Oldenziel’s comments on this thread. I disagree with many of you, but you presented a bunch of good arguments evidence on a thing that does actually seem quite important for the future of the world.
You might be interested in my old shortform on the military balance of power between US and China too. It’s a bit dated by now—the importance of drones has become much more clear by now [I think the evidence that we are in a military technological revolution on par with the introduction of guns] but you may find it of interest regardless.
I have lots of uncertainty about this! For example, it does appear that China basically gutted its software startup industry a few months ago, and this is really costly, and it wouldn’t surprise me if this will have large negative effects on Chinese drone effectiveness, since software seems like a non-trivial fraction of the difficulty, especially for coordinating drone swarms.
My current model is that overall, all things considered, the Chinese market economy is a lot weaker. This doesn’t mean there are no domains where China excells at building great products in their market economy, but I have a much higher likelihood that something will mess up their efforts to do something in the market than I have for the U.S.. IDK, I am at like 65% that the US market economy is sufficiently stronger here to produce a long-run advantage in drone manufacturing if the US government decides to spend heavily on it, which really isn’t that confident.
Since I feel like these kinds of discussions can often feel thankless, I felt like I wanted to write an explicit comment saying I am grateful for @1a3orn’s, @JohnofCharleston’s, @Thomas Kwa’s and @Alexander Gietelink Oldenziel’s comments on this thread. I disagree with many of you, but you presented a bunch of good arguments evidence on a thing that does actually seem quite important for the future of the world.
Much appreciated Habryka-san!
You might be interested in my old shortform on the military balance of power between US and China too. It’s a bit dated by now—the importance of drones has become much more clear by now [I think the evidence that we are in a military technological revolution on par with the introduction of guns] but you may find it of interest regardless.