Honestly, a lot of my work on this website consists of trying to write “the generalized version” of something that’s bothering me that would not otherwise be of philosophical interest. I just think this has a pretty good track record of being philosophically productive! For example, you yourself have linked to my philosophy of language work, even though you probably don’t care about the reason I originally got so obsessed with the philosophy of language in the first place. To me, that’s an encouraging sign that I got the philosophy right (rather than the philosophy being thinly-veiled politics).
Yes, I think this instinct has mostly served you well. In this instance, though, it appears to me to cross some hard-to-define line, maybe because it’s about drama I’m tangentially involved in?
I roughly think that the previous post was more clearly on the “frontpage side” than this one, and this one is edge-casey. (I’m only one of the mods and we don’t all agree all the time, but for people modeling where the line is in mod-judgment-aggregate, uh, that’s my current take)
Honestly, a lot of my work on this website consists of trying to write “the generalized version” of something that’s bothering me that would not otherwise be of philosophical interest. I just think this has a pretty good track record of being philosophically productive! For example, you yourself have linked to my philosophy of language work, even though you probably don’t care about the reason I originally got so obsessed with the philosophy of language in the first place. To me, that’s an encouraging sign that I got the philosophy right (rather than the philosophy being thinly-veiled politics).
Yes, I think this instinct has mostly served you well. In this instance, though, it appears to me to cross some hard-to-define line, maybe because it’s about drama I’m tangentially involved in?
I roughly think that the previous post was more clearly on the “frontpage side” than this one, and this one is edge-casey. (I’m only one of the mods and we don’t all agree all the time, but for people modeling where the line is in mod-judgment-aggregate, uh, that’s my current take)