LLM transcription is IMO a completely different use-case (one I certainly didn’t think of when thinking about the policy above), so in as much as the editing post-transcription is light, you would not need to put it into an LLM block. I also think structural edits by LLMs are basically totally fine, like having LLMs suggest moving a section earlier or later, which seems like the other thing that would be going on here.
We intentionally made the choice that light editing is fine, and heavy editing is not fine (where the line is somewhere between “is it doing line edits and suggesting changes to a relatively sparse number of individual sentences, or is it rewriting multiple sentences in a row and/or adding paragraphs”).
Also just de-facto, none of the posts you link trigger my “I know it when I see it” slop-detector, so you are also fine on that dimension.
Gotcha. I would feel reasonably happy if the policy said “text written or dictated by a human”, if we count my level of LLM editing followed by me editing to be overall light editing
LLM transcription is IMO a completely different use-case (one I certainly didn’t think of when thinking about the policy above), so in as much as the editing post-transcription is light, you would not need to put it into an LLM block. I also think structural edits by LLMs are basically totally fine, like having LLMs suggest moving a section earlier or later, which seems like the other thing that would be going on here.
We intentionally made the choice that light editing is fine, and heavy editing is not fine (where the line is somewhere between “is it doing line edits and suggesting changes to a relatively sparse number of individual sentences, or is it rewriting multiple sentences in a row and/or adding paragraphs”).
Also just de-facto, none of the posts you link trigger my “I know it when I see it” slop-detector, so you are also fine on that dimension.
Gotcha. I would feel reasonably happy if the policy said “text written or dictated by a human”, if we count my level of LLM editing followed by me editing to be overall light editing
Seems reasonable IMO!