I’ve no objection to making our comments into a top-level post. My only concern (which has nothing to do with its being our comments rather than anyone else’s) is that this would fall firmly into the category of discussion of the community rather than discussion of the things the community is about, and maybe that’s a thing we want less of rather than more.
It occurs to me that I said something ambiguous. By “I’ve no objection to making our comments into a top-level post” I meant “I’ve no objection to our comments being made into a top-level post”; I wasn’t saying anything about my willingness or unwillingness to do the work myself.
… I suppose I should answer the obvious followup question. I don’t mind doing the work myself but if I do it’s likely to be quite some time before I get round to it. If someone else does the work I don’t mind offering constructive criticism, corrections, etc., and would probably be quicker about doing that.
Apology accepted, obviously.
I’ve no objection to making our comments into a top-level post. My only concern (which has nothing to do with its being our comments rather than anyone else’s) is that this would fall firmly into the category of discussion of the community rather than discussion of the things the community is about, and maybe that’s a thing we want less of rather than more.
Ah, gotcha. Maybe make it a Meta post in this case.
Yeah, I think it should be Meta.
It occurs to me that I said something ambiguous. By “I’ve no objection to making our comments into a top-level post” I meant “I’ve no objection to our comments being made into a top-level post”; I wasn’t saying anything about my willingness or unwillingness to do the work myself.
… I suppose I should answer the obvious followup question. I don’t mind doing the work myself but if I do it’s likely to be quite some time before I get round to it. If someone else does the work I don’t mind offering constructive criticism, corrections, etc., and would probably be quicker about doing that.
I actually went ahead and did it last night (wording was ambiguous but seemed to imply you weren’t up for it in near future anyway)
So here it is. If you feel any of my commentary is misrepresenting you let me know.