everyone who’s saying they’re not convinced is talking about B.
Not everyone. The single highest-voted comment on the subject asks for “any attempt to extend and replicate this success” and “If it actually were a failure, how would we know? Would anyone there even admit it, or prefer to avoid making its leaders look bad?” While Academician’s subjective assessment adds nothing to Anna Salamon’s survey, the comment about hiring Luke actually addresses these complaints.
Not everyone. The single highest-voted comment on the subject asks for “any attempt to extend and replicate this success” and “If it actually were a failure, how would we know? Would anyone there even admit it, or prefer to avoid making its leaders look bad?” While Academician’s subjective assessment adds nothing to Anna Salamon’s survey, the comment about hiring Luke actually addresses these complaints.
No, he was also talking about B (link).