I was rereading HP Lovecraft’s The Call of Cthulhu lately, and the quote from the Necronomicon jumped out at me as a very good explanation of exactly why cryonics is such a good idea.
(Full disclosure: I myself have not signed up for cryonics. But I intend to sign up as soon as I can arrange to move to a place where it is available.)
Er… logical fallacy of fictional evidence, maybe? I wince every time somebody cites Terminator in a discussion of AI. It doesn’t matter if the conclusion is right or wrong, I still wince because it’s not a valid argument.
The original quote has nothing to do with life extension/immortality for humans. It just happens to be an argument for cryonics, and it seems to be a valid one: death as failure to preserve rather than cessation of activity, mortality as a problem rather than a fixed rule.
I was rereading HP Lovecraft’s The Call of Cthulhu lately, and the quote from the Necronomicon jumped out at me as a very good explanation of exactly why cryonics is such a good idea.
(Full disclosure: I myself have not signed up for cryonics. But I intend to sign up as soon as I can arrange to move to a place where it is available.)
The quote is simply this:
.
Er… logical fallacy of fictional evidence, maybe? I wince every time somebody cites Terminator in a discussion of AI. It doesn’t matter if the conclusion is right or wrong, I still wince because it’s not a valid argument.
The original quote has nothing to do with life extension/immortality for humans. It just happens to be an argument for cryonics, and it seems to be a valid one: death as failure to preserve rather than cessation of activity, mortality as a problem rather than a fixed rule.
.
RationalWiki is extremely sceptical of cryonics and still it has quoted that.
It featured prominently in last year’s Solstice.
.
http://lesswrong.com/lw/1pq/rationality_quotes_february_2010/1js5
(Full disclosure: I myself don’t intend to sign up for cryonics.)
Huh… Before posting the quote I did try searching to see if it had already been posted before, but that didn’t show up. Oh well.