I agree. But I claim saying “I can’t talk about the game itself, as that’s forbidden by the rules” is like saying “I won’t talk about the game itself because I decided not to”—the underlying reason is unclear.
The original reasoning that Eliezer gave if I remember correctly was that it’s better to make people realize there are unknown unknowns, rather than taking one specific strategy and saying “oh, I know how I would have stopped that particular strategy”
I agree. But I claim saying “I can’t talk about the game itself, as that’s forbidden by the rules” is like saying “I won’t talk about the game itself because I decided not to”—the underlying reason is unclear.
The original reasoning that Eliezer gave if I remember correctly was that it’s better to make people realize there are unknown unknowns, rather than taking one specific strategy and saying “oh, I know how I would have stopped that particular strategy”
Yes, this was Eliezer’s reasoning and both me and Ra ended up keeping the rule unchanged.