Are separate comment pages even desirable? Couldn’t the comment link be replaced with the anchor link which scrolls to the relevant comment (currently “see in context”)?
It’s a hotly debated topic! I think they are good because they provide a scroll-insensitive link to a piece of contend. Other people find them annoying. Maybe eventually we will find a UI solution that makes everyone happy.
Are separate comment pages even desirable? Couldn’t the comment link be replaced with the anchor link which scrolls to the relevant comment (currently “see in context”)?
It’s a hotly debated topic! I think they are good because they provide a scroll-insensitive link to a piece of contend. Other people find them annoying. Maybe eventually we will find a UI solution that makes everyone happy.