I’m pretty consequentialist and its hard to predict the effects of Eliezer’s harsh criticism of Jef Albright, but in the absence of a compelling argument that it is for the better, I would not be so mean.
That said, Jef’s comments were (perhaps unintentionally) condescending.
As for their substantive disagreement, I have little to add to what they and other commentators are contributing.
@Eliezer, why not try certain psychoactive drugs?