I’m pretty consequentialist and its hard to predict the effects of Eliezer’s harsh criticism of Jef Albright, but in the absence of a compelling argument that it is for the better, I would not be so mean.
That said, Jef’s comments were (perhaps unintentionally) condescending.
As for their substantive disagreement, I have little to add to what they and other commentators are contributing.
I’m pretty consequentialist and its hard to predict the effects of Eliezer’s harsh criticism of Jef Albright, but in the absence of a compelling argument that it is for the better, I would not be so mean.
That said, Jef’s comments were (perhaps unintentionally) condescending.
As for their substantive disagreement, I have little to add to what they and other commentators are contributing.