I was responding to the ‘why would anyone ever use Parseltongue’ comment. It’s interesting that Dumbledore understands Parseltongue, and he is the major person to keep the conversation secret from, but note that Parseltongue would protect against many other factions, and unless the agent had a taperecorder handy or something, it’d also protect against any agent/ally of Dumbledore (if not the man himself), of which there are many.
(I personally don’t think ‘hissing’, for Snape or Quirrel, indicates Parseltongue use—that’s a major secret and would be indicated more strongly.)
I was responding to the ‘why would anyone ever use Parseltongue’ comment. It’s interesting that Dumbledore understands Parseltongue, and he is the major person to keep the conversation secret from, but note that Parseltongue would protect against many other factions, and unless the agent had a taperecorder handy or something, it’d also protect against any agent/ally of Dumbledore (if not the man himself), of which there are many.
(I personally don’t think ‘hissing’, for Snape or Quirrel, indicates Parseltongue use—that’s a major secret and would be indicated more strongly.)
I wasn’t referring to you specifically, so much as the train of thought extending from:
That definitely seems like overthinking to me, considering how commonly someone hisses in literature.
Though I admit, it would be a great security precaution—which is precisely why Quirrel and Harry do so when the topic is sensitive, as has been said.