It creates competition, yes, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing. Personally I’ve found karma to be a great motivator in trying to write good comments and posts. For me, the top ten list is a considerable motivator—trying to achieve it has been part of the reason why I’ve been as active as I have been. I probably won’t be able to reach it—there are other people who are consistently even more productive—but even then I try not to end up too far from the lowest-ranking people on it. I even think it might be good if people could bring up a list of all contributors as ranked by karma, not just the top ten.
Karma does create an incentive to write more and better comments. Still, the question is what alternative are you foregoing to write the marginal comment at LW? Should the top ten competition skew your investment of time toward LW comments and away from that alternative? Is it rational if it does?
It creates competition, yes, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing. Personally I’ve found karma to be a great motivator in trying to write good comments and posts. For me, the top ten list is a considerable motivator—trying to achieve it has been part of the reason why I’ve been as active as I have been. I probably won’t be able to reach it—there are other people who are consistently even more productive—but even then I try not to end up too far from the lowest-ranking people on it. I even think it might be good if people could bring up a list of all contributors as ranked by karma, not just the top ten.
Karma does create an incentive to write more and better comments. Still, the question is what alternative are you foregoing to write the marginal comment at LW? Should the top ten competition skew your investment of time toward LW comments and away from that alternative? Is it rational if it does?