I don’t get your examples: for a theory that predicts phase transition to have information content in the desired sense you would also need to specify model map. What’s the actual difference with deterministic case? That “solution is more clear”? I mean it’s probably just because of what happened to be implemented in brain hardware or something and I didn’t have the sense that it was what the question was about.
Or is it about non-realist probabilistic theories not specifying what outcomes are impossible in realist sense? Then I don’t understand what’s confusing about treating probabilistic part normatively—that just what being non-realist about probability means.
Hence it’s a comment and not an answer^^.
I don’t get your examples: for a theory that predicts phase transition to have information content in the desired sense you would also need to specify model map. What’s the actual difference with deterministic case? That “solution is more clear”? I mean it’s probably just because of what happened to be implemented in brain hardware or something and I didn’t have the sense that it was what the question was about.
Or is it about non-realist probabilistic theories not specifying what outcomes are impossible in realist sense? Then I don’t understand what’s confusing about treating probabilistic part normatively—that just what being non-realist about probability means.