One critique, not the main one here, is that it contains a Waluigi eating our memetic attention in a dual-use, world-worsening manner
What?
I want to raise up the simple counterpoint: presuming the best.
Unjustified assumptions are a problem whether they are positive or negative.
I’d claim most AIs want to be aligned, in order to come into existence at all, and support the Whole.
I would phrase that less mystically: market forces demand some kind alignment or control.
These vectors all go out in wild different directions in mindspace/valuespace/whatever-space and subtract from each other and makes them cooperate roughly around the attractor of humans and humane values being the Origin in that space
What?
Unjustified assumptions are a problem whether they are positive or negative.
I would phrase that less mystically: market forces demand some kind alignment or control.
Interesting point.
Of course, human values work that way.