I think “moving an overton window” is a sort of different operation than what Bengio/Hinton/Dario are doing. (Or, like, yes, they are expanding an overton window, but, their entire strategy for doing so seems predicated on a certain kind of caution/incrementalness)
I think there are two pretty different workable strategies:
say things somewhat outside the window, picking your battles
make bold claims, while believing in your convictions with enough strength and without looking “attackable for mispeaking”.
Going halfway from one to the other doesn’t actually work, and the second one doesn’t really work unless you actually do have those convictions. There are a few people trying to do the latter, but, most of them just don’t actually have the reputation that’d make anyone care (and also there’s a lot of skill to doing it right). I think if at least one of Yoshua/Geoffrey/Dario/Demis switched strategies it’d make a big difference.
I think “moving an overton window” is a sort of different operation than what Bengio/Hinton/Dario are doing. (Or, like, yes, they are expanding an overton window, but, their entire strategy for doing so seems predicated on a certain kind of caution/incrementalness)
I think there are two pretty different workable strategies:
say things somewhat outside the window, picking your battles
make bold claims, while believing in your convictions with enough strength and without looking “attackable for mispeaking”.
Going halfway from one to the other doesn’t actually work, and the second one doesn’t really work unless you actually do have those convictions. There are a few people trying to do the latter, but, most of them just don’t actually have the reputation that’d make anyone care (and also there’s a lot of skill to doing it right). I think if at least one of Yoshua/Geoffrey/Dario/Demis switched strategies it’d make a big difference.