I changed it to ‘lead for frontier policy at Google DeepMind’.
To be fair, this post has two parts:
Directly addressing your points
Addressing other arguments against RCA or making general counterarguments, some of which you didn’t make
I can see that the second part seems a bit unfair to you and is probably not helpful in trying to convince you here. I have seen people literally making the point that RCA means we are totally fine.
I do however still think that RCA totally does not apply here, maybe I am wrong and there will be some transition period where it briefly applies, but I really don’t see even that argument at the moment. Currently humans have an absolute advantage at a shrinking number of tasks which keeps us employed for the moment.
I changed it to ‘lead for frontier policy at Google DeepMind’.
To be fair, this post has two parts:
Directly addressing your points
Addressing other arguments against RCA or making general counterarguments, some of which you didn’t make
I can see that the second part seems a bit unfair to you and is probably not helpful in trying to convince you here. I have seen people literally making the point that RCA means we are totally fine.
I do however still think that RCA totally does not apply here, maybe I am wrong and there will be some transition period where it briefly applies, but I really don’t see even that argument at the moment. Currently humans have an absolute advantage at a shrinking number of tasks which keeps us employed for the moment.
If you read my post as uncharitable and have 40 minutes to spare, you may read The tale of the Top Tier intellect by Yud.