Note: The comment link in the post seems broken from LW. Maybe that’s a GreaterWrong specific link syntax, but LW uses hashtags with comment ids, instead of a /comments/<commentId> syntax.
Yep, API wise this should be relatively straightforward, though it will require doing some database mutations, so it might take us a bit longer than usual. In particular, we don’t know from just looking at a comment whether the post it was posted to was on the frontpage, or in meta, or anywhere else, so we will have to add some additional metadata there.
Note: The comment link in the post seems broken from LW. Maybe that’s a GreaterWrong specific link syntax, but LW uses hashtags with comment ids, instead of a /comments/<commentId> syntax.
Ah yes, sorry; /comments/<commentId> is the GW URL pattern for individual-comment-thread permalinks (like on old LW).
Yep, API wise this should be relatively straightforward, though it will require doing some database mutations, so it might take us a bit longer than usual. In particular, we don’t know from just looking at a comment whether the post it was posted to was on the frontpage, or in meta, or anywhere else, so we will have to add some additional metadata there.
Ah, I see, thanks. Well, whenever you are able to get to it, this would definitely be appreciated!
Note: The comment link in the post seems broken from LW. Maybe that’s a GreaterWrong specific link syntax, but LW uses hashtags with comment ids, instead of a
/comments/<commentId>syntax.Yep, API wise this should be relatively straightforward, though it will require doing some database mutations, so it might take us a bit longer than usual. In particular, we don’t know from just looking at a comment whether the post it was posted to was on the frontpage, or in meta, or anywhere else, so we will have to add some additional metadata there.
Ah yes, sorry;
/comments/<commentId>is the GW URL pattern for individual-comment-thread permalinks (like on old LW).Ah, I see, thanks. Well, whenever you are able to get to it, this would definitely be appreciated!
Actually I like and use the mixed comment feed.
I’d like an, “ancient comment feed” for any posts older than a year. So that those can get some. Responsive activity.
I would not be against separate feeds as well, so long as we don’t lose the mixed feed.