I don’t think “true if big” is a good claim to make? Plenty of things have gotten big that aren’t true, and the argument ‘move’ of “noticing that someone’s claim proves a lot” is a good one to make without implying the converse.
(epistemic status: yes, I am aware the parent comment is a joke) (joke status: poor. explaining the joke makes it worse)
I don’t think “true if big” is a good claim to make? Plenty of things have gotten big that aren’t true, and the argument ‘move’ of “noticing that someone’s claim proves a lot” is a good one to make without implying the converse.
(epistemic status: yes, I am aware the parent comment is a joke)
(joke status: poor. explaining the joke makes it worse)