Which instantly changes the problem domain from equality to social outcomes
I am not changing the subject, I am disagreeing with the claim that redistribution is only justified by equality.
Communism is bullshit. It never works
Non communist societies can have redistribution, so that is simply irrelevant.
Show me a single society where nobody ever refuses to pay, and they are never subjected to force to remedy that.
“Revolution” is not defined as “any use of force whatsoever” , so, irrelevant again.
If we are both forced to give some for the benefit of all then I can live with that. It’s called tax
And what is, taken in tax is partly redistributed, so you are not talking about a fundamentally different thing.
You might object to more extreme forms of redistribution, but then it would have been helpful to say so explicitly.
[edits for spelling and clarity]
I am not changing the subject, I am disagreeing with the claim that redistribution is only justified by equality.
Non communist societies can have redistribution, so that is simply irrelevant.
“Revolution” is not defined as “any use of force whatsoever” , so, irrelevant again.
And what is, taken in tax is partly redistributed, so you are not talking about a fundamentally different thing.
You might object to more extreme forms of redistribution, but then it would have been helpful to say so explicitly.
[edits for spelling and clarity]