I guess the first vote means “whatever my vote would be under the old system”.
The second vote… I am not sure how to apply it e.g. to your comment. If I click “agree”, what does it mean?
I agree that Duncan intuitively expected the first/left vote to be agree/disagree, and the second/right vote to be good standards? [yes]
It also seems to me that the first/left vote is agree/disagree, and the second/right vote is good standards? [no]
I guess I am just going to use the first vote as usual (now if you vote “agree” on this comment, does it mean “yes, I believe this is exactly what Viliam will do” or “yes, I will do the same thing”?), and the second one only in situations that seem unambiguous.
I’ve been doing a lot of ‘overall’ voting based on “all things considered, am I happy this comment exists?” or “would I like to see more comments like this in the future?” and ‘agreement’ voting on specifically “do I endorse its contents?”
For a non-charged example, I upvoted Duncan’s comment suggesting that the buttons be swapped, because I think that a good kind of feedback to give on an experiment, and voted disagree on it because I don’t think swapping would have the effect he thinks it would have.
Another example: if two people are having a back and forth where they seem to remember different things, I’ll normal vote for both of them because I’m glad they’re hashing it out, but I won’t agree/disagree with any of them because I don’t have any inside information on what happened.
I am confused.
I guess the first vote means “whatever my vote would be under the old system”.
The second vote… I am not sure how to apply it e.g. to your comment. If I click “agree”, what does it mean?
I agree that Duncan intuitively expected the first/left vote to be agree/disagree, and the second/right vote to be good standards? [yes]
It also seems to me that the first/left vote is agree/disagree, and the second/right vote is good standards? [no]
I guess I am just going to use the first vote as usual (now if you vote “agree” on this comment, does it mean “yes, I believe this is exactly what Viliam will do” or “yes, I will do the same thing”?), and the second one only in situations that seem unambiguous.
I’ve been doing a lot of ‘overall’ voting based on “all things considered, am I happy this comment exists?” or “would I like to see more comments like this in the future?” and ‘agreement’ voting on specifically “do I endorse its contents?”
For a non-charged example, I upvoted Duncan’s comment suggesting that the buttons be swapped, because I think that a good kind of feedback to give on an experiment, and voted disagree on it because I don’t think swapping would have the effect he thinks it would have.
Another example: if two people are having a back and forth where they seem to remember different things, I’ll normal vote for both of them because I’m glad they’re hashing it out, but I won’t agree/disagree with any of them because I don’t have any inside information on what happened.