Your proposal would be net positive but the question is whether it’s better than Plan A. Even if takeoff is very slow post-deal if you didn’t advance ai capabilities much during the deal or use them heavily to do useful work then you get much less benefit from the deal than in Plan A.
I think it’s pretty likely that if you start a very serious pause, with compute chain dismantling, then the race doesn’t restart for a very long time. And in the meantime, the world might just become a better place by default. I find it relatively plausible that in the next hundred years, the world would make as much progress towards democracy, stability and peace as Europe made since 1926. If US and China and the other great powers of 2126 will be on as friendly terms as France and Germany are now, then I will feel much better about slowly restarting AI development. If you think that the deal is very likely to break early, or if you don’t believe that the default secular trends in the world point in a good direction, then admittedly this less promising.
Your proposal would be net positive but the question is whether it’s better than Plan A. Even if takeoff is very slow post-deal if you didn’t advance ai capabilities much during the deal or use them heavily to do useful work then you get much less benefit from the deal than in Plan A.
I think it’s pretty likely that if you start a very serious pause, with compute chain dismantling, then the race doesn’t restart for a very long time. And in the meantime, the world might just become a better place by default. I find it relatively plausible that in the next hundred years, the world would make as much progress towards democracy, stability and peace as Europe made since 1926. If US and China and the other great powers of 2126 will be on as friendly terms as France and Germany are now, then I will feel much better about slowly restarting AI development. If you think that the deal is very likely to break early, or if you don’t believe that the default secular trends in the world point in a good direction, then admittedly this less promising.
See https://ai-2040.com/supplements/deal-decline for my probabilistic estimates here.