The problem of counterfactuals is not just the problem of defining them.
The problem of counterfactuals exists for rationalists only: they are not considered a problem in mainstream philosophy.
The rationalist problem of countefactuals is eminently disolvable. You start making realistic assumptions about agents: that they have incomplete world-models, and imperfect self-knowledge.
The problem of counterfactuals is not just the problem of defining them.
The problem of counterfactuals exists for rationalists only: they are not considered a problem in mainstream philosophy.
The rationalist problem of countefactuals is eminently disolvable. You start making realistic assumptions about agents: that they have incomplete world-models, and imperfect self-knowledge.
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/yBdDXXmLYejrcPPv2/two-alternatives-to-logical-counterfactuals