And when I tried to analyzed my certainty that – even despite the whole multiple intelligences thing – I couldn’t possibly be as good as them, it boiled down to something like this: they were talented at hard things, but I was only talented at easy things.
It took me about ten years to figure out the flaw in this argument, by the way.
Let’s say that you and I decide to play pool. We agree to play eight-ball, best of five games. Our perception is that what follows is a contest to see who will do something called winning.
But I don’t see it that way. I always imagine the outcome of eight-ball to be predetermined, to about 95% certainty, based on who has practiced that specific skill the most over his lifetime. The remaining 5% is mostly luck, and playing a best of five series eliminates most of the luck too.
I’ve spent a ridiculous number of hours playing pool, mostly as a kid. I’m not proud of that fact. Almost any other activity would have been more useful. As a result of my wasted youth, years later I can beat 99% of the public at eight-ball. But I can’t enjoy that sort of so-called victory. It doesn’t feel like “winning” anything.
It feels as meaningful as if my opponent and I had kept logs of the hours we each had spent playing pool over our lifetimes and simply compared. It feels redundant to play the actual games.
This reminds me of my criteria for learning: “You have understood something when it appears to be easy.”
The mathematicians call this state ‘trivial’.
It has become easy because you trained the topic until the key aspects became part of your unconscious competence. Then it appears to yourself as easy—because you no longer need to think about it.
Reminds me of something Scott said once:
See also: The Illusion of Winning by Scott Adams (h/t Kaj_Sotala)
This reminds me of my criteria for learning: “You have understood something when it appears to be easy.” The mathematicians call this state ‘trivial’. It has become easy because you trained the topic until the key aspects became part of your unconscious competence. Then it appears to yourself as easy—because you no longer need to think about it.