If I go to someone’s overview page, click the permalink for one of their comments, and then click the title at the top of the permalinked comment such that I’m back at the full article, it always shows up with this problem (“MAIN” in bold and related misleading issues).
Just tried it by going to army1987′s overview page, clicking the permalink to here, and clicking the title up top. You can try following the link and clicking up to see the effect on this thread.
If I remember correctly, other kinds of shenanigans happen with user pages and comment lists, though in this case I think I understand why the permalink causes issues.
That’s probably one way that people get them, but I think Army is right that google is another, and I doubt that google is getting them that way. Maybe google gets them from r/all? (the redirection todo I mentioned above would solve the google problem)
For the record:
If I go to someone’s overview page, click the permalink for one of their comments, and then click the title at the top of the permalinked comment such that I’m back at the full article, it always shows up with this problem (“MAIN” in bold and related misleading issues).
Just tried it by going to army1987′s overview page, clicking the permalink to here, and clicking the title up top. You can try following the link and clicking up to see the effect on this thread.
If I remember correctly, other kinds of shenanigans happen with user pages and comment lists, though in this case I think I understand why the permalink causes issues.
That’s probably one way that people get them, but I think Army is right that google is another, and I doubt that google is getting them that way. Maybe google gets them from r/all? (the redirection todo I mentioned above would solve the google problem)