Well, lots of people already figured actual uploading was only possible by simulating the brain as a physical object, and thus not likely to be all that good—brains are complicated, and Kurzweil way oversimplifies. Have you seen the news that our brains use long-range electric fields in computation? The choices I see if we have to be simulated as physical objects are “use lots of rules of thumb to get a fast-running probably-human-like AI” and “try for fidelity and get a slow-running human.”
So the effect exists, and appears to be used. If you remember the magic disconnected gates in the famous evolved circuit, I think it’s very safe to say that it’s used.
I am a bit surprised if this is surprising—is it not obvious that electric fields will affect neuron activity. Whether a neuron fires depends on the voltage across its membrane (at a point in a particular region at the base of the axon and, it seems, down the axon). The electric field around the neuron will affect this voltage difference as in good old-fashioned electrical theory. This is important for synchrony in firing (as in the brain waves) and that is important for marking synapses between neurons that have fired simultaneously for chemical changes. etc. etc. etc. Fields are not to be thought of as a little side effect.
What is more interesting is what the fields do to glial cells and their communication which is (I believe) carried out with calcium ions but very affected by electrical fields. The synapses live in an environment created by the surrounding glia.
The brain cannot be reduced to a bunch of on-off switches.
Well, lots of people already figured actual uploading was only possible by simulating the brain as a physical object, and thus not likely to be all that good—brains are complicated, and Kurzweil way oversimplifies. Have you seen the news that our brains use long-range electric fields in computation? The choices I see if we have to be simulated as physical objects are “use lots of rules of thumb to get a fast-running probably-human-like AI” and “try for fidelity and get a slow-running human.”
No—do you have a link?
http://media.caltech.edu/press_releases/13401
So the effect exists, and appears to be used. If you remember the magic disconnected gates in the famous evolved circuit, I think it’s very safe to say that it’s used.
Really nifty. I summarized both here, although the full articles are short enough, and are worth reading.
I am a bit surprised if this is surprising—is it not obvious that electric fields will affect neuron activity. Whether a neuron fires depends on the voltage across its membrane (at a point in a particular region at the base of the axon and, it seems, down the axon). The electric field around the neuron will affect this voltage difference as in good old-fashioned electrical theory. This is important for synchrony in firing (as in the brain waves) and that is important for marking synapses between neurons that have fired simultaneously for chemical changes. etc. etc. etc. Fields are not to be thought of as a little side effect. What is more interesting is what the fields do to glial cells and their communication which is (I believe) carried out with calcium ions but very affected by electrical fields. The synapses live in an environment created by the surrounding glia. The brain cannot be reduced to a bunch of on-off switches.