A thing I’m finding difficult at the moment is that criticism just isn’t really indexed in a consistent way, because, well, everyone has subtly different frames on what they’re criticizing and why.
It’s possible there should be, like, 3 major FAQs that just try to be a comprehensive index on frequent disagreements people have with LW consensus, and people who want to argue about it are directed there to leave comments, and maybe over time the FAQ becomes even more comprehensive. It’s a lot of work, might be worth it anyway
(I’m imagining such an FAQ mostly linking to external posts rather than answering everything itself)
A thing I’m finding difficult at the moment is that criticism just isn’t really indexed in a consistent way, because, well, everyone has subtly different frames on what they’re criticizing and why.
It’s possible there should be, like, 3 major FAQs that just try to be a comprehensive index on frequent disagreements people have with LW consensus, and people who want to argue about it are directed there to leave comments, and maybe over time the FAQ becomes even more comprehensive. It’s a lot of work, might be worth it anyway
(I’m imagining such an FAQ mostly linking to external posts rather than answering everything itself)