Looking forward to reading your take on superalignment. I wanted to get my thoughts out here but would really like there to be a good reference document with all the core counterarguments. When I read Will’s post, I it seemed sad that I didn’t know of a well argued paper or post to point to against superalignment.
When discussing the quality of a plan, we should assume that a company (and/or government) is really trying to make the plan work and has some lead time.
I agree that some of my arguments don’t directly address the best version of the plan, but rather what realistically is actually happening. I do think that proponents should give us some reason why they believe they will have time to implement the plan. I think they should also explain why they don’t think this plan will have negative consequences.
Looking forward to reading your take on superalignment. I wanted to get my thoughts out here but would really like there to be a good reference document with all the core counterarguments. When I read Will’s post, I it seemed sad that I didn’t know of a well argued paper or post to point to against superalignment.
I agree that some of my arguments don’t directly address the best version of the plan, but rather what realistically is actually happening. I do think that proponents should give us some reason why they believe they will have time to implement the plan. I think they should also explain why they don’t think this plan will have negative consequences.
I think John’s anti-control post is the best I know of