As I understand it:
UDT > FDT > CDT > EDT
Breakdown:
UDT > FDT
FDT doesn’t pay in ‘The Counterfactual Mugging,’ because it updates, while UDT doesn’t (hence ‘updateless’).
FDT > CDT
In Newcomb’s Problem FDT one-boxes, while CDT two-boxes.
CDT > EDT
In Newcomb’s Soda, or ‘Smoking Lesion’, CDT does not accept that (in the absence of a time machine) your actions affect the past.
Transitivity:
UDT and FDT ‘agree with’ CDT on Newcomb’s Soda.
UDT ‘agrees with’ FDT on Newcomb’s problem.
As I understand it:
UDT > FDT > CDT > EDT
Breakdown:
UDT > FDT
FDT doesn’t pay in ‘The Counterfactual Mugging,’ because it updates, while UDT doesn’t (hence ‘updateless’).
FDT > CDT
In Newcomb’s Problem FDT one-boxes, while CDT two-boxes.
CDT > EDT
In Newcomb’s Soda, or ‘Smoking Lesion’, CDT does not accept that (in the absence of a time machine) your actions affect the past.
Transitivity:
UDT and FDT ‘agree with’ CDT on Newcomb’s Soda.
UDT ‘agrees with’ FDT on Newcomb’s problem.