For OpenAI, I claim the cyber, CBRN, and persuasion Critical thresholds are very high (and also the cyber High threshold). I agree the autonomy Critical threshold doesn’t feel so high.
For Anthropic, most of the action is at ASL-4+, and they haven’t even defined the ASL-4 standard yet. (So you can think of the current ASL-4 thresholds as infinitely high. I don’t think “The thresholds are very high” for OpenAI was meant to imply a comparison to Anthropic; it’s hard to compare since ASL-4 doesn’t exist. Sorry for confusion.)
Briefly:
For OpenAI, I claim the cyber, CBRN, and persuasion Critical thresholds are very high (and also the cyber High threshold). I agree the autonomy Critical threshold doesn’t feel so high.
For Anthropic, most of the action is at ASL-4+, and they haven’t even defined the ASL-4 standard yet. (So you can think of the current ASL-4 thresholds as infinitely high. I don’t think “The thresholds are very high” for OpenAI was meant to imply a comparison to Anthropic; it’s hard to compare since ASL-4 doesn’t exist. Sorry for confusion.)