I think the “increase in sensory acuity is an increase in introspective access to signal already present” point is central to understanding meditation, Circling, and their similarity, and think your post makes that point well.
If you just mean the version of “empiricism” where “knowledge comes only or primarily from sensory experience”, then I think it does a good job of pointing at how it’s trying to do that. I think there are important connotations of empiricism that are missing, tho; like, what is the sensory experience of? This is what I’ve vaguely gesturing at with the “nourishing properties of the universe” thing; if I look at a thermometer, I’m trying to get my sense data to connect to ‘objective reality’; if I look at my own thoughts, the connection to ‘objective reality’ is more tenuous. It’s not absent; and I think having some sort of reflective practice is a good idea, but I feel like Circling can make a stronger case than “a corollary of meditation.”
Would be curious to hear how well you and Vaniver think that my recent post on meditation makes the case for “meditation as a form of empiricism”.
I think the “increase in sensory acuity is an increase in introspective access to signal already present” point is central to understanding meditation, Circling, and their similarity, and think your post makes that point well.
If you just mean the version of “empiricism” where “knowledge comes only or primarily from sensory experience”, then I think it does a good job of pointing at how it’s trying to do that. I think there are important connotations of empiricism that are missing, tho; like, what is the sensory experience of? This is what I’ve vaguely gesturing at with the “nourishing properties of the universe” thing; if I look at a thermometer, I’m trying to get my sense data to connect to ‘objective reality’; if I look at my own thoughts, the connection to ‘objective reality’ is more tenuous. It’s not absent; and I think having some sort of reflective practice is a good idea, but I feel like Circling can make a stronger case than “a corollary of meditation.”
That makes sense, thanks!