I think both of those are basically fine. The thing that I’m more worried about is stuff like:
Alice: “This organization is unethical, you shouldn’t support it”
Bob: “Why?”
Alice: *no response*
It’s very understandable that one might not be able to share all their evidence or fully explicate everything, but I think that providing at least some information is important.
I think both of those are basically fine. The thing that I’m more worried about is stuff like:
It’s very understandable that one might not be able to share all their evidence or fully explicate everything, but I think that providing at least some information is important.
Sure, this seems reasonable. I am also worried about content-free praise, but, independent of that, content-free criticism seems good to discourage.