I am mostly uninterested in whether or not it’s pejorative. I think it’s descriptively accurate.
This discussion has implications on the validity of rationalism on its own terms, and also on how others should relate to rationalism.
The question is about what-is-true, but the reason we’re interested is what-is-good. This means we all have to be extra careful to keep our what-is-good boxes separate from our what-is-true boxes (I’m not accusing you of failing to do so).
I think that’s what you’re implying above, you’re saying “im not calling you names. I’m actually thinking about this!”, which is good. But what you said is dishonest.
It does have implications, and you are interested in them (for good reason)
Nevertheless, a worldview centered on preventing an imminent apocalypse is extremely easy to weaponize.
[...]
Cults are just religious sects that are new, horrible, or both.
My people have something called the Litany of Tarski, for just these situations. It is from one of our most ancient texts.
If [rationalsim is a cult], I want to believe that [rationalism is a cult]. If [rationalism is not a cult], I want to believe that [rationalism is not a cult]. Let me not become attatched to beliefs I do not want.
This discussion has implications on the validity of rationalism on its own terms, and also on how others should relate to rationalism.
The question is about what-is-true, but the reason we’re interested is what-is-good. This means we all have to be extra careful to keep our what-is-good boxes separate from our what-is-true boxes (I’m not accusing you of failing to do so).
I think that’s what you’re implying above, you’re saying “im not calling you names. I’m actually thinking about this!”, which is good. But what you said is dishonest.
It does have implications, and you are interested in them (for good reason)
My people have something called the Litany of Tarski, for just these situations. It is from one of our most ancient texts.
If [rationalsim is a cult], I want to believe that [rationalism is a cult]. If [rationalism is not a cult], I want to believe that [rationalism is not a cult]. Let me not become attatched to beliefs I do not want.