If I informed you (1) that I would prefer that you choose to kill me rather than allow five other people to die so I could go on living, would that change the morally right thing to do? (Note I’m not asking you what you would do in that situation.)
==
(1) I mean convincingly informed you, not just posted a comment about it that you have no particular reason to take seriously. I’m not sure how I could do that, but just for concreteness, suppose I had Elspeth’s power.
(EDIT: Actually, it occurs to me that I could more simply ask: “If I preferred...,” given that I’m asking about your moral intuitions rather than your predicted behavior.)
Yes, if I had that information about your preferences, it would make it OK to kill you for purposes you approved. Your right to not be killed is yours; you don’t have to exercise it if you don’t care to.
OK, cool. Thanks.
If I informed you (1) that I would prefer that you choose to kill me rather than allow five other people to die so I could go on living, would that change the morally right thing to do? (Note I’m not asking you what you would do in that situation.)
==
(1) I mean convincingly informed you, not just posted a comment about it that you have no particular reason to take seriously. I’m not sure how I could do that, but just for concreteness, suppose I had Elspeth’s power.
(EDIT: Actually, it occurs to me that I could more simply ask: “If I preferred...,” given that I’m asking about your moral intuitions rather than your predicted behavior.)
Yes, if I had that information about your preferences, it would make it OK to kill you for purposes you approved. Your right to not be killed is yours; you don’t have to exercise it if you don’t care to.