Giving What We Can
members have pledged to donate at least 10% of what they earn to help
others as best they can, but this is broader than it was originally.
The pledge was specific to global poverty, and only became
cause-neutral
in late 2014 after
a
lot of discussion. I think that discussion is interesting to
review now that we can see how it worked out, and is probably more
interesting than continuing with this post below where I look at minor
wording changes.
But, if you want to stick around for my looking through the Internet Archive for minor wording
changes, here are the five versions it captured on the site.
I recognise that I can use part of my income to do a significant
amount of good in the developing world. Since I can live well enough
on a smaller income, I pledge that from today until the day I retire,
I shall give at least ten percent of what I earn to whichever
organizations can most effectively use it to fight poverty in
developing countries. I make this pledge freely, openly, and without
regret.
I recognise that I can use part of my income to do a significant
amount of good in the developing world. Since I can live well enough
on a smaller income, I pledge that for the rest of my life or until
the day I retire, I shall give at least ten percent of what I earn to
whichever organisations can most effectively use it to help people in
developing countries, now and in the years to come. I make this pledge
freely, openly, and sincerely.
This expansion brought in things like interventions that save lives
without necessarily making people less poor, interventions that take a
while to pay off, and even reducing
existential risk (provided that you think it’s still worth it when
only including the benefit to people in developing counties). I can’t
find any discussion of this at the time, but if there was please
point me to it!
The big change was a few months later, sometime between 2014-11-27
and 2015-01-07,
when they changed it to:
I recognise that I can use part of my income to do a significant
amount of good. Since I can live well enough on a smaller income, I
pledge that for the rest of my life or until the day I retire, I shall
give at least ten percent of what I earn to whichever organisations
can most effectively use it to improve the lives of others, now and in
the years to come. I make this pledge freely, openly, and sincerely.
Expanding the pledge to be cause netural was very
controversial: people were worried it would dilute what GWWC stood
for, and hurt its credibility. On the other hand, there’s a lot of
value in having a pledge we can all stand behind, plus encouraging
people to make a lifetime committment to a specific cause is contrary
to a lot of what EA stands for.
Changes since then have been pretty minor. Between 2020-09-07
and 2020-09-19
it gained some blanks for expiration and amount:
I recognise that I can use part of my income to do a significant
amount of good. Since I can live well enough on a smaller income, I
pledge that from now until __ I shall give __ to whichever
organisations can most effectively use it to improve the lives of
others, now and in the years to come. I make this pledge freely,
openly, and sincerely.
Asking GWWC, they said this was to allow one version of the main text
to cover what had previously required othervariants.
Later, between 2022-02-08
and 2022-02-13
it gained one last blank, for the start date:
I recognise that I can use part of my income to do a significant
amount of good. Since I can live well enough on a smaller income, I
pledge that from __ until __ I shall give __ to whichever
organisations can most effectively use it to improve the lives of
others, now and in the years to come. I make this pledge freely,
openly, and sincerely.
Asking GWWC again, this was to cover both cases where someone was
intending to start on a future date, and also cases where people
wanted to pick a date in the past so the pledge would cover earlier
income.
Disclosure: my wife used to be
President of GWWC, but I haven’t run this post by her and I don’t know
her views here. I sent a draft of this post to GWWC.
GWWC Pledge History
Link post
Giving What We Can members have pledged to donate at least 10% of what they earn to help others as best they can, but this is broader than it was originally. The pledge was specific to global poverty, and only became cause-neutral in late 2014 after a lot of discussion. I think that discussion is interesting to review now that we can see how it worked out, and is probably more interesting than continuing with this post below where I look at minor wording changes.
But, if you want to stick around for my looking through the Internet Archive for minor wording changes, here are the five versions it captured on the site.
The first one is 2011-07-26, with:
Sometime between 2014-02-08 and 2014-06-03 the pledge was changed to:
This expansion brought in things like interventions that save lives without necessarily making people less poor, interventions that take a while to pay off, and even reducing existential risk (provided that you think it’s still worth it when only including the benefit to people in developing counties). I can’t find any discussion of this at the time, but if there was please point me to it!
The big change was a few months later, sometime between 2014-11-27 and 2015-01-07, when they changed it to:
Expanding the pledge to be cause netural was very controversial: people were worried it would dilute what GWWC stood for, and hurt its credibility. On the other hand, there’s a lot of value in having a pledge we can all stand behind, plus encouraging people to make a lifetime committment to a specific cause is contrary to a lot of what EA stands for.
Changes since then have been pretty minor. Between 2020-09-07 and 2020-09-19 it gained some blanks for expiration and amount:
Asking GWWC, they said this was to allow one version of the main text to cover what had previously required other variants.
Later, between 2022-02-08 and 2022-02-13 it gained one last blank, for the start date:
Asking GWWC again, this was to cover both cases where someone was intending to start on a future date, and also cases where people wanted to pick a date in the past so the pledge would cover earlier income.
Disclosure: my wife used to be President of GWWC, but I haven’t run this post by her and I don’t know her views here. I sent a draft of this post to GWWC.