Sarah asked if the math wasn’t a bit overkill: were the calculations really necessary to make the basic point that good definitions should be about classifying the world, rather than about what’s pleasant or politically expedient to say?
I thought the math was important as an appeal to principle—and as intimidation. (As it was written, the tenth virtue is precision!Even if you cannot do the math, knowing that the math exists tells you that the dance step is precise and has no room in it for your whims.)
FYI I found the math pretty valuable (even though I didn’t sit through and check it). Specifically for the reason you list here that I bolded.
FYI I found the math pretty valuable (even though I didn’t sit through and check it). Specifically for the reason you list here that I bolded.