If you consider the ideas of John Taylor Gatto, the 1991 New York State teacher of the year, regarding schooling, you might hesitate before using the word “schooling” to mean something credible.
Yeah, I’ve read some of what he says. He’s right and he’s wrong; American public education is indeed designed to produce workers, but we still have far more entrepreneurs per capita than, say, China.
Hmmm. Not to ignore the fact that this essentially sidesteps my point that school should not necessarily be associated with credibility, but you’ve succeeded in making me curious: what do you think the difference is between the US and China that would explain that?
Actually, I think I’m wrong on the facts here; The GEM 2011 Global Report has some tables about this, but they don’t copy/paste very well. The U.S. is ranked first in “early-stage entrepreneurial activity” (percentage of the population that owns or is employed by a business less than three and a half years old) among nations characterized as “innovation-driven economies” (a category that includes most of Europe, Japan, and South Korea) at 12.3%, but “efficiency-driven economies” (which includes China, most of Latin America, and much of Eastern Europe) tend to have higher values; China is listed at 24.0%,
If you consider the ideas of John Taylor Gatto, the 1991 New York State teacher of the year, regarding schooling, you might hesitate before using the word “schooling” to mean something credible.
His perspective is that schooling is not education and can help or hinder learning (explained under the heading “Learning, Schooling, & Education”). The criticisms he provides in “Dumbing us Down” are pretty nasty. I gave the gist of it and linked to an online book preview here. I highly recommend reading at least the first chapter of that book.
Yeah, I’ve read some of what he says. He’s right and he’s wrong; American public education is indeed designed to produce workers, but we still have far more entrepreneurs per capita than, say, China.
Hmmm. Not to ignore the fact that this essentially sidesteps my point that school should not necessarily be associated with credibility, but you’ve succeeded in making me curious: what do you think the difference is between the US and China that would explain that?
Actually, I think I’m wrong on the facts here; The GEM 2011 Global Report has some tables about this, but they don’t copy/paste very well. The U.S. is ranked first in “early-stage entrepreneurial activity” (percentage of the population that owns or is employed by a business less than three and a half years old) among nations characterized as “innovation-driven economies” (a category that includes most of Europe, Japan, and South Korea) at 12.3%, but “efficiency-driven economies” (which includes China, most of Latin America, and much of Eastern Europe) tend to have higher values; China is listed at 24.0%,