CEV extrapolates the volition of humanity, that’s one reason it has to be “coherent”.
In your proposal, people have autonomy, but this principle can be violated in “extremely dangerous” situations. People are free to do what they want (“volition”)… but their AI advisors look ahead (“extrapolated”)… and people are not allowed to exercise their freedom so as to jeopardize the freedom of others (“coherent”).
CEV extrapolates the volition of humanity, that’s one reason it has to be “coherent”.
In your proposal, people have autonomy, but this principle can be violated in “extremely dangerous” situations. People are free to do what they want (“volition”)… but their AI advisors look ahead (“extrapolated”)… and people are not allowed to exercise their freedom so as to jeopardize the freedom of others (“coherent”).