The grounds to avoid discouraging people from walking into hospitals are way stronger than the grounds to avoid discouraging people from being hermits.
So you think that the only problem with the Transplant scenario is that it discourages people from using hospitals..?
Not the only one, but the deal-breaking one.
See this
Well, that’s the standard rationalization utilitarians use to get out of that dilemma.
The grounds to avoid discouraging people from walking into hospitals are way stronger than the grounds to avoid discouraging people from being hermits.
So you think that the only problem with the Transplant scenario is that it discourages people from using hospitals..?
Not the only one, but the deal-breaking one.
See this
Well, that’s the standard rationalization utilitarians use to get out of that dilemma.