Don’t think positive and negative sensations or experiences lie on the same continuous line of “goodness”
This seems like a global modifier which is a function of your mental health. High levels of mental well-being seems to make people grateful even for their negative experiences.
Would agree that negative experiences are bad, and more of them is even worse
That negative experiences are experienced as bad does not mean that they’re bad, it means that experiencing certain things as bad is good. For instance, when you feel exhausted, your body still has lots of energy left, it merely creates the illusion that you’re running empty in order to prevent you from harming yourself. Negative experiences are also just signals that something isn’t right, but having the experience is valuable, and avoiding the experience might merely prevent you from learning that something needs changing. Saying that pain is bad in itself is like saying that the smoke alarm in your kitchen is bad. Suffering isn’t damage, it’s defense against damage.
Would agree that’s it’s immoral to create more negative experience (or in some cases fail to reduce the amount of negative experience)
Negative experiences can create good outcomes (because, as I said earlier the felt ‘badness’ is an illusion and thus not objective negative utility). And I dislike that axiom because it says “it’s better to die at birth than to grow old” (the latter will have more negative experiences).
Would not agree that it’s immoral to fail to create more positive experiences (or reduce the amount of positive experience someone has)
I’m the rare sort of person who does take this into account and deem it important. I’d go as far as to say “If you have a lot of positive experiences, you will be able to shrug off more negative experiences with a laugh”.
In short, the brain lies to itself because there’s utility in these lies, but if you believe in these lies, then you cannot come to the correct conclusions about this topic. For the rest of the conclusions one may arrive at, I think they depend on the mental health of the speaker, and not on their intelligence. The sentence “Life is suffering” is not an explanation for why people are feeling bad, it’s a product of people feeling bad. Cause and effect goes in the other direction than what is commonly believed.
This seems like a global modifier which is a function of your mental health. High levels of mental well-being seems to make people grateful even for their negative experiences.
That negative experiences are experienced as bad does not mean that they’re bad, it means that experiencing certain things as bad is good. For instance, when you feel exhausted, your body still has lots of energy left, it merely creates the illusion that you’re running empty in order to prevent you from harming yourself. Negative experiences are also just signals that something isn’t right, but having the experience is valuable, and avoiding the experience might merely prevent you from learning that something needs changing. Saying that pain is bad in itself is like saying that the smoke alarm in your kitchen is bad. Suffering isn’t damage, it’s defense against damage.
Negative experiences can create good outcomes (because, as I said earlier the felt ‘badness’ is an illusion and thus not objective negative utility). And I dislike that axiom because it says “it’s better to die at birth than to grow old” (the latter will have more negative experiences).
I’m the rare sort of person who does take this into account and deem it important. I’d go as far as to say “If you have a lot of positive experiences, you will be able to shrug off more negative experiences with a laugh”.
In short, the brain lies to itself because there’s utility in these lies, but if you believe in these lies, then you cannot come to the correct conclusions about this topic. For the rest of the conclusions one may arrive at, I think they depend on the mental health of the speaker, and not on their intelligence. The sentence “Life is suffering” is not an explanation for why people are feeling bad, it’s a product of people feeling bad. Cause and effect goes in the other direction than what is commonly believed.