There’s a technical sense in which writing a piece of computer software consumes electricity and calories and so it’s not “from nothing”, but I think that that framing does more to obscure than to illuminate the difference that I’m pointing to.
If the total value of everything in the wizard’s workshop is higher when they finish than it was when they started, then I think it makes sense to say that the wizard has created value, even if they needed some precursors to get the process started.
Software is kind of an exceptional case because computers are made to be incredibly easy to update. So the cost of installing software can be neglected relative to the cost of making the software.
There’s a technical sense in which writing a piece of computer software consumes electricity and calories and so it’s not “from nothing”, but I think that that framing does more to obscure than to illuminate the difference that I’m pointing to.
If the total value of everything in the wizard’s workshop is higher when they finish than it was when they started, then I think it makes sense to say that the wizard has created value, even if they needed some precursors to get the process started.
Software is kind of an exceptional case because computers are made to be incredibly easy to update. So the cost of installing software can be neglected relative to the cost of making the software.