They stopped talking after they taboo’d “rational”. Both can agree that CDT recommends one thing, and EDT recommends another, but if you dropped them into Omega’s lap right now they would still disagree over which decision theory to use. They replaced the word with their own respective spins on its meaning, but they failed to address the real hidden query in the label: Is this the best course of action for a reasonable person to take?
They stopped talking after they taboo’d “rational”. Both can agree that CDT recommends one thing, and EDT recommends another, but if you dropped them into Omega’s lap right now they would still disagree over which decision theory to use. They replaced the word with their own respective spins on its meaning, but they failed to address the real hidden query in the label: Is this the best course of action for a reasonable person to take?