You can add my #10 to your list. Regarding your new #8, I’m not sure I understand the distinction between a brain implemented on a computer chip vs a simulation of a brain. Regarding my opinion on what is “intuitively true”, it seems like all of them are different ways of making more precise the notion of identity, I don’t know that it makes sense to give one of them a privileged status. In other words they all seem to be referring to slightly different concepts, all of which appear to be valid...
You can add my #10 to your list. Regarding your new #8, I’m not sure I understand the distinction between a brain implemented on a computer chip vs a simulation of a brain. Regarding my opinion on what is “intuitively true”, it seems like all of them are different ways of making more precise the notion of identity, I don’t know that it makes sense to give one of them a privileged status. In other words they all seem to be referring to slightly different concepts, all of which appear to be valid...