We will have to return to definitions then. Can you have a game without players? Can you have a player without intentions? It is like arguing whether the Face on Mars is really a face. It is not the product of intention, but it does indeed look like a face. Is looking like a face enough for it to be a face? Deep Blue “plays chess” if you define chess as occurring whenever there is a conformance to certain appearances. But if chess requires the presence of a mind possessing certain minimal concepts and intentions, then Deep Blue in itself does not play chess.
I’m not talking about parts. I’m talking about the game Chess itself (or an instance thereof).
We will have to return to definitions then. Can you have a game without players? Can you have a player without intentions? It is like arguing whether the Face on Mars is really a face. It is not the product of intention, but it does indeed look like a face. Is looking like a face enough for it to be a face? Deep Blue “plays chess” if you define chess as occurring whenever there is a conformance to certain appearances. But if chess requires the presence of a mind possessing certain minimal concepts and intentions, then Deep Blue in itself does not play chess.