I wonder if it would be useful to give users a checkbox like “If this post is not selected for the frontpage, please tell me why” (in the same way scientific journals will tell you why your submission was rejected).
Yeah I was actually just thinking today about a “feedback appreciated” option (I can imagine versions of this that are appropriate for “feedback from anyone” and “feedback from admins”)
I don’t know that we can promise to give feedback to everyone all the time, but it does seem like something that’d be valuable as often as is practical (esp for people who opt into it)
I wonder if it would be useful to give users a checkbox like “If this post is not selected for the frontpage, please tell me why” (in the same way scientific journals will tell you why your submission was rejected).
Yeah I was actually just thinking today about a “feedback appreciated” option (I can imagine versions of this that are appropriate for “feedback from anyone” and “feedback from admins”)
I don’t know that we can promise to give feedback to everyone all the time, but it does seem like something that’d be valuable as often as is practical (esp for people who opt into it)