Also, if you’re asking a panel of people, even those skilled at strategic thinking will still be useless unless they’ve thought deeply about the particular question or adjacent ones. And skilled strategic thinkers can get outdated quickly if they haven’t thought seriously about the problem in awhile.
I’m not trying to agree with that one. I think that if someone has thought a bunch about the general topic of AI and has a bunch of useful takes. They can probably convert this on the fly to something somewhat useful, even if it’s not as reliable as it would be if they spent a long time thinking about it. Like I think I can give useful technical mechanistic interpretability takes even if the question is about topics I’ve not spent much time thinking about before
yeah there’s generalization, but I do thing that eg (AGI technical alignment strategy, AGI lab and government strategy, AI welfare, AGI capabilities strategy) are sufficiently different that experts at one will be significantly behind experts on the others
Also, if you’re asking a panel of people, even those skilled at strategic thinking will still be useless unless they’ve thought deeply about the particular question or adjacent ones. And skilled strategic thinkers can get outdated quickly if they haven’t thought seriously about the problem in awhile.
I’m not trying to agree with that one. I think that if someone has thought a bunch about the general topic of AI and has a bunch of useful takes. They can probably convert this on the fly to something somewhat useful, even if it’s not as reliable as it would be if they spent a long time thinking about it. Like I think I can give useful technical mechanistic interpretability takes even if the question is about topics I’ve not spent much time thinking about before
yeah there’s generalization, but I do thing that eg (AGI technical alignment strategy, AGI lab and government strategy, AI welfare, AGI capabilities strategy) are sufficiently different that experts at one will be significantly behind experts on the others
If a strategy is likely to be outdated quickly it’s not robust and not a good strategy. Strategies should be able to withstand lots of variation.